The Idea of Hegel's "Science of Logic"

By Stanley Rosen

Although Hegel considered Science of Logic essential to his philosophy, it has got scant remark in comparison with the opposite 3 books he released in his lifetime. the following thinker Stanley Rosen rescues the Science of Logic from obscurity, arguing that its forget is accountable for modern philosophy’s fracture into many various and antagonistic colleges of proposal. via deep and cautious research, Rosen sheds new gentle at the designated difficulties that animate Hegel’s missed booklet and their super importance to philosophical conceptions of good judgment and reason.

Rosen’s overarching query is how, if in any respect, rationalism can triumph over the break up among monism and dualism. Monism—which claims a novel essence for all things—ultimately results in nihilism, whereas dualism, which claims a number of, irreducible essences, results in what Rosen calls “the unending chatter of the background of philosophy.” The Science of Logic, he argues, is the basic textual content to provide a brand new perception of rationalism that will conquer this philosophical break up. best readers via Hegel’s publication from commencing to finish, Rosen’s argument culminates in a masterful bankruptcy at the inspiration in Hegel. via absolutely appreciating theScience of Logic and situating it effectively inside of Hegel’s oeuvre, Rosen in flip presents new instruments for wrangling with the conceptual puzzles that experience introduced such a lot of different philosophers to disaster.

Show description

Preview of The Idea of Hegel's "Science of Logic" PDF

Similar Philosophy books

The Landscape of History: How Historians Map the Past

What's heritage and why should still we learn it? Is there this type of factor as old fact? Is heritage a technology? probably the most entire historians at paintings at the present time, John Lewis Gaddis, solutions those and different questions during this brief, witty, and humane publication. The panorama of background offers a looking examine the historian's craft, in addition to a powerful argument for why a historic attention may still topic to us this present day.

Natural-Born Cyborgs: Minds, Technologies, and the Future of Human Intelligence

From Robocop to the Terminator to Eve eight, no photo greater captures our inner most fears approximately know-how than the cyborg, the person that is either flesh and steel, mind and electronics. yet thinker and cognitive scientist Andy Clark sees it otherwise. Cyborgs, he writes, aren't anything to be feared--we already are cyborgs.

Kabbalah: A Very Short Introduction

In Kabbalah: a really brief creation, Joseph Dan, one of many world's major professionals on Jewish mysticism, bargains a concise and hugely exact examine the heritage and personality of a few of the structures built via the adherents of the Kabbalah. Dan sheds mild at the many misconceptions approximately what Kabbalah is and isn't--including its connections to magic, astronomy, alchemy, and numerology--and he illuminates the connection among Kaballah and Christianity at the one hand and New Age faith at the different.

Phenomenology of Spirit

This tremendous examine of the levels within the mind's important development from instant sense-consciousness to the placement of a systematic philosophy contains an introductory essay and a paragraph-by-paragraph research of the textual content to assist the reader comprehend this so much tough and such a lot influential of Hegel's works.

Extra resources for The Idea of Hegel's "Science of Logic"

Show sample text content

And via “concept,” Hegel is referring to not a finite and separate artifact of considering yet relatively to the dwelling job of the deliberating spirit. The natural Anschauen of being is attentiveness to attentiveness, or the preliminary manifestation of noēsis tēs noēseōs. Being is the being of the idea that. that's to assert, it's not the taking into consideration whatever, yet “empty considering” (72). Empty considering, in spite of the fact that, remains to be pondering. seeing that there's not anything else to be had, it needs to be the contemplating pondering, no longer within the feel of greedy its personal nature or constitution yet within the feel of being “at the prepared” or attentive. One may possibly item to this that i've got outfitted self-consciousness or complexity into Hegel’s formula, yet that's not what i've got in brain. natural being is natural considering; if there have been no attentiveness, there will be no considering. “Thinking of considering” has not anything as such to do with self-consciousness; this can be a later degree of improvement. however, there continues to be an issue for my research within the shift from being to not anything. instantly after selecting empty being as empty pondering, Hegel says: “Being, the indeterminate speedy, is in reality not anything and not anything extra nor below not anything” (72). it really is something to claim that vacant pondering isn't the considering something yes. however it is anything else to assert that vacant pondering is not anything. Hegel has simply pointed out empty pondering as being, and being is definitely the being of the concept that in its preliminary conceptual prestige as missing all next determinations. “Nothing” needs to hence seek advice from the absence of all next determinations. yet being, extra exactly the being of the idea that, isn't really not anything. Let’s take this up via turning to subsection B. booklet 1, part 1, bankruptcy 1, Subsection B: not anything “Nothing, natural not anything; it's easy sameness [Gleichheit] with itself, entire vacancy, loss of choice and content material, undifferentiatedness in itself” (72). This appears to be like very on the subject of the hole account of natural being, however the resemblance conceals an immense distinction. The vacancy of natural being isn't the comparable because the vacancy of natural not anything. natural not anything might even be the absence of being. In different phrases, natural not anything is the “altogether no longer” opposed to which Parmenides warns us, while the Hegelian not anything is the absence of determinations inside of natural being. Hegel’s “pure” not anything isn't natural, regardless of his statement that it's so. As Hegel himself makes specific, the concept that, or considering, and so natural being, has no longer disappeared within the transition from subsection A to subsection B. Hegel proceeds to improve a similar aspect approximately Anschauen with recognize to not anything that he constructed with admire to being. “Insofar as Anschauen or considering could be pointed out the following, so it counts as a distinction if anything or not anything is apprehended or concept. The getting to or considering not anything has accordingly a which means [Bedeutung] . . . ” I holiday off the citation to remark. it truly is as significant to talk of apprehending not anything because it is to talk of apprehending anything, however the which means is assorted.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.25 of 5 – based on 14 votes